Gotham Steel Pan Reviews 2017: The Truth About Gotham Steel Cookware

If you are in charge of preparing meals for your family, like I am, you surely know how frustrating is when your food burns. In that moment, you put your cooking skills in doubt (you certainly cannot be called amateur), karma, and even Jamie Oliver’s competency because you did everything as he said and still you have smoking, undefined black mass in your pan.

To prevent food from sticking (and eventually burning), I have been adding gallons of oil and changing the temperature on the stove at least million times during the cooking until I finally found the solution - change the pan!

After my revolutionary discovery, I’ve ordered my first non-stick pan. I didn’t know much about Gotham Steel Pans, but I thought that it was worth a shot. And oh boy, it was!

Gotham-Steel-Pan-Reviews

I’ve decided to test my new Gotham Steel Pan before informing the rest of my family that the new era of impeccable taste coming from my kitchen has come. I started with the basics: grilled cheese. Firstly, I was surprised that I didn’t need to add oil and secondly, it didn’t stick at all, and it was perfectly fried. After that, I fried eggs, baked and even flambéed desserts with same, extraordinary results.

Everyone should enjoy the features these pans bring, and that is why I’m going to help you find the best Gotham Steel Pan for your kitchen with five Gotham Steel Pan reviews, practical advice on using these products and differences. Let’s start!

What are Gotham Steel Pans?

Image Credit: Gotham Steel Pan

Gotham Steel pans are made of super strong titanium and non-stick ceramic surface. The high-quality titanium is used to provide durability so that you could use these pans for extended periods of time. Also, Gotham Steel Pans are made of non-toxic materials that are perfectly safe for both children and adults.

Although these non-stick pans are made of titanium, they have perfect weight – not too heavy and not too light. The Gotham Steel Pan manufacturer knows how important is to have a perfectly balanced and light-weight pan especially in situations when you need to move it from the stove or to take food out of it.

Gotham Steel Pans maintenance is more than easy because they can be washed in the dishwasher without the concern of damaging. If you don’t have the time to clean it immediately after cooking, just fill it with hot water and soap to avoid residue from drying and wipe the pan with the paper towel.

Is Gotham Steel Pan Safe?

​It’s okay to be concerned about product’s safety especially if you haven’t used it before. The best way to dispel your doubts is to get informed about the used materials, and I will help you with that.

Gotham Steel Pan is made of entirely safe materials that do not contain any harmful or toxic components. The non-stick coating is PFOA-free and PFOS-free, and even at high temperatures, it doesn’t release any toxic materials into the air.

You can be sure that even if you wash the pan in the dishwasher, use metal cookware or wire for cleaning the pan’s surface, the non-stick and non-scratch coating won’t get damaged or chip away. Also, the surface of the pan won’t leave the gray marks on the food which was the case with pans from disingenuous manufacturers.

Does Gotham Steel Pan Really Work?

You maybe saw this commercial on TV, but to be honest, I wasn’t. I was reading the Gotham Steel Pan Reviews to gain the knowledge on these products and make my buying decision, and it was well worth it.

Gotham Steel Pan is advertised to have a non-stick cooking surface. This further means that you won’t need to use oil or any type of fats to prepare meals. This way they will be very healthy, and perfect for people who concentrate on healthy lifestyle or people on a diet.

This surface is also a non-scratch surface which means you can use metal cookware directly in it, even whisk eggs in it without any fear of damaging it.

To prove all this, Gotham Steel Pan was tested in many TV shows:

Check out the video where Josh Capon demonstrates the Gotham Steel Pan’s amazing features:

Still, as buyers, we’re all aware of the TV commercials; everything is perfect, the food looks amazing, and everybody is happy. Real life doesn’t work like that.

Because I am a cautious buyer, I have started my own research to find out what are other people’s experiences and reviews. You just can’t rely on infomercials these days. It turned out that Gotham Steel Pan really works. Nowadays, many sites and reviewers post videos on YouTube where they complain or praise the good experience they had with the product, and this pan received more praise than complaints.

If you want to check it by yourself, just go on the YouTube and in search menu type: “Gotham Steel Pan Review” and you will see the documented performance of this pan.

Bonus: How to Use Gotham Steel Pan

Gotham Steel Pan vs. Red Copper Pan vs. Copper Chef Pan​

Gotham Steel Pan

Red Copper Pan

Copper Chef Pan

Endorsed by

Daniel Green

Cathy Mitchell

Eric Theiss

Material Type

Ceramic, titanium, and stainless steel

Ceramic combined with tough copper infusion

Ceramic, stainless steel, and tempered glass

Coating

PTFE/PFOA/PFOS Free

PFOA & PTFE Free

PFOA & PTFE Free

Dishwasher Safe

Yes

Yes

Yes

Oven Safe

Yes

Yes

Yes

Heat Resistance

Up to 500°F

Up to 500°F

Up to 850°F

Good for

Flaky Salmon / Grill Steak / Flambé Recipes

Flambé / Broil / Shallow Fry / Stir Fry / Whip Ingredients

Roast / Bake / Deep Fry / Steam

Price

$$$

$$$

$$$

Editor Rating

Anyone who enjoys spending time in the kitchen will know that one of the most important factors for cookware, especially pans, is the non-stick feature. We all had that one or more disappointments when we bought a frying pan which was advertised as a non-stick but it turned out to be a false claim. As soon as the coating got scratched, the cooking became a nightmare and potentially unsafe.

The new generation of non-stick cookware definitely performs better, and provides high value. Gotham Steel is not the only brand on the market today; there are two more similar yet rivalry products out there – Red Copper Pans and Copper Chef Pans. So what’s the difference between them?

The Red Copper Pan also features non-stick ceramic, only this time infused with the durability of copper. The ceramic will ensure the non-stick convenience while the copper will make it very durable and will not scratch and peel off. It heats very quickly giving these type of pans great cooking abilities with its equal heat distribution.

Also, Red Copper Pans are lightweight yet strong and allow you to flambé, shallow fry or broil without problems. Red Copper Pan is PFOA and PTFE free meaning it does not contain any harmful toxins nor chemicals. It is a worthy adversary to the Gotham Steel Pans with just a few differences.

​Click here to read my full review of the Red Copper Pan

Now, the Copper Chef Pan comes with the Cerami-Tech patent in ceramic surface enhancements. This patent provides denser and thicker walls of the pan making it more suitable for higher temperatures withstanding up to incredible 850-degree temperature without being damaged. Also, it is PFOA and PTFE free similar to the Red Copper Pans while Gotham Steel Pans are also PFOS free.

However, the Copper Chef Pans seem to be somewhat more expensive than the other two but with almost same non-stick feature. It will retain the nonstick ability for a decent period but shorter than Red Copper Pan and maybe longer than Gotham Steel Pan.

​Click here to read my full review of the Copper Chef Pan

The values, features, and characteristics that products from these brands possess imply to original products. If your product doesn’t have the quality of the products we review and describe, you’ve probably got a fake replica from a disingenuous seller.

Gotham Steel Pan Reviews 2017

Let’s take a look at the reviews of the five best Gotham Steel pans of our choice that you can get on Amazon.com today.​

1. Gotham Steel 9.5 inches Non-stick Titanium Frying Pan​

Image credit: Amazon.com

Endorsed by Chef Daniel Green, The Gotham Steel 9.5 inches Non-stick Titanium Frying Pan combines non-stick ceramic with very strong titanium in an attempt to create the ultimate frying pan. It is promised to deliver effortless food release to help you prepare a wide variety of food with no butter or oil needed for healthier cooking.

Also, it is said that this frying pan is safe to use with metal utensils since it features Non-Scratch technology. It is safe for dishwasher cleaning and it is PTFE/PFOA/PFOS free which is a standard. So let’s try it and see how true these claims are.

Being among the best versatile cookware, The Gotham Steel should outperform other non-stick frying pans allowing you to cut kitchen time in half. With Ti-Cerama coating, it combines ceramic and titanium, making it durable and non-stick pan on which you can cook virtually any food and without the messy cleanup.

As advertised on TV, it is able to slide anything and everything just right of it without the use of oil or butter. But it seems that it was too good to be true, at least for this particular product. Non-stick technology happens to be just the opposite since making a simple poached egg or omelet proved to be a not so simple task – it stuck to the pan, unfortunately.

On the bright side, this pan seems to work well on a low heat since it is very efficient in heat conducting. It is recommended to season the pan and to use it on a low to medium flame, and it just may save you the trouble of food sticking and cleaning afterward.

This pan comes in three sizes to choose from: 9.5-inches, 11-inches, 12.5 inches or a three-piece set in which all three mentioned before are included. It did not deliver some of the TV commercial promises since the food actually stuck on it at the test drive, but if you take special care before using this pan and make sure to season it properly – it will lessen the chance of food sticking to it.

  • Works well on low heat
  • Efficient heat conducting
  • Solidly constructed
  • Good weight, well balanced
  • Comes in three sizes
  • Small cooking surface
  • Not suitable for induction stove
  • Uncomfortable, thin handle

2. Gotham Steel Titanium Ceramic Deep Square Pan With Lid, Frying Basket, Steamer Tray

Image credit: Amazon.com

Gotham Steel Titanium Ceramic 9.5 Deep Square Frying and Cooking Pan is made of high-grade titanium and ceramic as finishing surface, as well as other Gotham Steel products. This proven combination should ensure maximum durability with multi-functional and all-around usage. Deep Square is a multi-piece product which features a stainless steel induction base with a lid, fry basket, and steam rack. Also, it is oven safe up to 500-degrees, dishwasher safe and of course PTFE/PFOA/PFOS free. Sounds about right, now it’s our turn to see if true or not.

Being a multi-piece product, it should certainly help you get rid of excessive cookware in your kitchen since it suitable for all sorts of cooking, working on the stove-top as well as in the oven. It features a fry basket which will allow you to drain off any excess oil giving you that crispy result not using all the grease and it works good.

Also, it includes the steamer which will get the best of your veggies while retaining all the nutrients and minerals and it does it well also. As mentioned before, it is made of strong titanium and a ceramic coating which, in this particular case, actually works as it’s supposed to.

However, do not expect it to be precisely deep as the manufacturer claims it to be because it is considerably shallower for some reason. Also, it is somewhat lighter than we expected which may give it some cheaper feel and look to it.

To wrap it all up, Deep Square has proven to be a worthy tool when it comes to versatility and consistency in what it was supposed to be doing. It is a good product, with a very reliable non-stick coating which did not fail in practice. It comes with a fry basket, steam rack, 9.5 diameter deep-dish pan, lid and a recipe guide providing everything you’ll need. Be aware that it is not suitable for induction cooktop cooking, so don’t even try it and if you expected a real cookbook – you’ll get only link to a downloadable copy. But that’s okay since it is overall an excellent purchase already.

  • Even cooking
  • Very easy to clean
  • Very versatile
  • Good non-stick coating
  • Doesn’t get scratched easily
  • Not suitable for induction cooktop
  • Not as deep as advertised
  • Does not come with a cookbook, but with link to downloadable copy
  • Lighter than expected

3. Gotham Steel Non-Stick Copper Grill Pan with Ti-Cerama Surface

Image credit: Amazon.com

Gotham Steel 10.5-inch Non-Stick Copper Grill Pan with Ti-Cerama Surface is the first product ever to feature a double-sided surface for double use and two times the energy. This unique feature is accomplished with a grill on one side, and griddle on the other, making it an amazingly versatile product. The groove on the sides will catch all the grease for later easy cleanup.

Ti-Cerama Cooking Surface with its high-heat threshold should make cooking come easily to you as well as cleaning since everything just slides right off, even if its burnt thanks to the non-stick surface. It is very versatile for stove-tops or even baking. The pan itself is ridged which will make your food have that tasty barbecue appeal and most importantly it is wide enough.

However, you should know that the ridges are not as deep as we would like them to be. Nevertheless, the ridges are a nice feature to have for they will provide that ribbed look on food even if it’s cooked on a stove. Also, it can be used on an outdoor grill which we really liked. One thing we also liked is that the pan surface is big enough measuring 10.5-inches length x 10.5-inches width respectively.​

One of the greatest features of this product is that it is very durable and rust-proof, the coating doesn’t peel off with constant washing after usage, and it is safe enough to put it into a dishwasher. But it should be noted that this pan can be a little bit shallow for certain consumers. There are some unpleasant reviews online about this one as well, because of the inconsistency compared to Red Copper pan performance.

  • High-grade ceramic
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Good for grilling and for cooking on stovetop
  • Double-sided surface
  • Cooks quickly
  • A bit shallow pan
  • Ridges could be deeper
  • Hard to remove the black paste
  • Difficult to clean

4. Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set

Image credit: Amazon.com

Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set are the first products of its class to utilize high-grade titanium and ceramic as their surface finishing really. This sophisticated and unique combination will ensure excellent durability, at the same time providing all-around and multi-functional usage.

These products are made with a combination of strong titanium paired with the non-stick ceramic coating delivering uncompromising efficiency.

Thanks to the Ti-Cerama surface featured in these products, they can be used for cooking without oil, butter or any kind of grease, while non-scratch surface will allow you to use metal utensils on it when mixing ingredients of your choice. It is perfectly suited of the stove-top or up to 500 degrees’ oven temperatures.

Another thing that is important to mention is that these products are safe for all cooktops but not for induction so be aware of that – it will not work on induction stove, so do not try it. Besides that, this set is very lightweight, rust-proof and made of stainless steel which is a nice feature to have in every kitchen. Also, it is dishwasher safe and, of course, PFOA. PTFE, and PFOS-free.​

This Gotham Steel Set includes 5-quart pot with lid, 2.5-quart pot with lid, 1.5-quart pot with lid, 8.5-inch pan, 10.25-inch pan with lid, steamer insert for a complete cookware set ideally suited for beginners as well as the professionals alike. These products are easy to clean as well as dishwasher-friendly as we mentioned. Of course, being scratch-proof doesn’t mean you are allowed to go berserk on it since it can get a little bit scratchy.

Also, the manufacturer’s claims aren’t backed up with field-tested results, so be aware of that when you use this set. Overall, this set seems a bit overpriced since it looks somewhat cheaply made, but it proved to be very durable and multi-functional which is very important.

  • Non-stick Ti-Cerama coating
  • Good for use on high heat
  • Multi-functional use
  • Very durable
  • Easy to clean up
  • Not so scratch-proof
  • Overpriced
  • Cheaply made
  • The bottom coating peels off

5. Gotham Steel Tastic Bundle 7 Piece Set Titanium Ceramic Pan

Image credit: Amazon.com

Gotham Steel Tastic Bundle 7 Piece Set combines 9.5-inch Deep Square Pan, 9.5-inch and 12.5-inch Frying Pan into one purchase. The benefits of Gotham Steel are well known since they include utilization of a high-grade titanium and ceramic as its finishing surface for greater durability, versatility and non-stick benefits: food doesn’t stick/no need for oil or butter/healthier diet. These pans are suitable for stove-top, cooking or baking. They are rust-proof all over, very easy to clean and dishwasher safe. Not to forget, they are 100% food safe or PFOA, PFTE, and PFOS-free.

As mentioned in our other reviews concerning the frying pans which are a part of this set, they could be more promising. In this case, we have a 9.5-inch version and a 12.5-inch version of the same frying pan. Unfortunately, these pans failed to deliver TV-commercial-famous non-stickiness, but just “out of the box” since seasoning the pan did the trick, at least for a while.

But still, these are premium quality frying pans, and when treated as such, they will deliver desired results. Deep Square 9.5-inch Pan is also included, and there aren’t many negative things to say about it. Titanium and ceramic coating are working as intended in terms of non-stick promise. It is not as deep as the manufacturer claims it to be, but that should not be an issue for most.

To sum it all up, here we have a seven-piece set composed of a very versatile deep square pan with a tempered glass lid, steamer tray, frying basket and a two versions of frying pans (9.5-inch and 12.5-inch). The recipe book is only included as a downloadable link which is actually a shame.

It should be noted that these are good quality products, solidly constructed, very lightweight, versatile and after all work is done – very easy to clean which is also important. There have been some minor issues with the frying pans regarding the non-stickiness, and not to forget that this cookware is not suitable for induction stoves. The overall impression is that you shouldn’t be disappointed with this purchase for what it’s worth.

  • Lightweight, well-balanced cookware
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Good quality, solidly constructed
  • Efficient heat conducting
  • Good non-stick deep square pan
  • Versatile cookware
  • Not so non-stick frying pans
  • Not suitable with induction stove
  • Not as deep square pan as declared
  • Cookbook in the form of a downloadable copy

Since I’ve had the chance to investigate and test all five Gotham Steel products, in my opinion (after more than 56 hours of research and testing), if you intend to buy the best Gotham Steel Pan in 2017, you won’t miss with Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set. These premium quality products are all made of a combination of very strong titanium and non-stick ceramic coating and include: 5-quart pot with lid, 2.5-quart pot with lid, 1.5-quart pot with lid, 8.5-inch pan, 10.25-inch pan with lid, and steamer insert. It is a complete cookware set which is ideally suited for professionals as well for beginners.

These products are meant to be used without butter, oil or any kind of grease allowing you to cook healthier meals. Also featured is the non-scratch surface which means that you are allowed to use any kind of metal utensils on it while you mix your favorite ingredients. But do not push it, since it is only a precautionary measure.

Also mentionable is that these products are suitable for stovetops and ovens up to 500-degrees. And when the all cooking is done, this set is enjoyably easy to clean and not to forget that it is dishwasher-friendly.

So, what can we say more? All the pluses are on the side of this set, and it was really hard to find any mentionable downsides. That’s why, for all these reasons, I believe that Gotham Steel 10-Piece Kitchen Nonstick Frying Pan and Cookware Set is the absolute winner and you will not regret this recommendable purchase.

Barbara Whitney
 

For the last 20 years, I’ve been cooking, preparing, researching, and gathering recipes, tools, and knowledge about food and the way we prepare it. Raising two lively boys and spoiling one great husband later, it’s safe to say that I’ve optimized my kitchen to deliver the best possible meal, no matter the occasion.