Best Cocktail Shaker Reviews 2017: Top 5+ Recommended

Have you ever had a cocktail party?

John and I love organizing them.

We have been holding cocktail parties for a couple of years now. Inviting guests over, chatting, laughing and, of course, drinking cocktails. I don't think there's a better way to catch up with friends.

I have decided to try out different cocktail shakers and see if anyone would react or notice and, as it turns out, the quality of the cocktail does depend on the shaker.

For the past couple of months, I have been using a different shaker at every party, which led me to decide which is the best cocktail shaker for me.

Here’s what you need to know to do it yourself:

What Is A Cocktail Shaker?

A cocktail shaker is a device which is used for mixing beverages by shaking, and it should be shaken for enough time to mix all the ingredients together.

Cocktail shakers are usually used for making a martini, but there are a lot of other cocktails that you simply have to try.

Barbara: Dry Manhattan is my favorite, how about yours?

Different Types of Cocktail Shakers

There are three types of cocktail shakers:

  1. The Boston Cocktail Shaker
  2. The Cobbler Cocktail Shaker
  3. The French Cocktail Shaker

1. The Boston Cocktail Shaker

This shaker comes in two pieces, a large metal tumbler, and a mixing glass and it is the easiest to recognize of all three types.

These two parts are easy to separate, no matter if it's hot or cold.

This shaker is good for when you are making a cocktail of a certain color because you can clearly see through the glass.

The disadvantage is that it is large, which makes it harder to control.

2. The Cobbler Cocktail Shaker

This type of shaker comes in three pieces, a large metal tumbler and a metal lid with a built-in strainer.

What I love about this type of shaker is that it is easy to control and that is all thanks to the strainer.

The problem with this type of shakers is that, when you’re mixing cold drinks, it is tough to separate them.

3. The French Cocktail Shaker

Most people call this the original cocktail shaker.

This one consists of two pieces, a large metal tumbler, and a metal lid and it is incredibly easy to use if you ignore the fact that it is hard to separate.

This type is really popular, although it lacks the strainer that the cobbler shaker has.

If you like the retro style, you will love this type of shakers; it really looks lovely.

What To Look For In A Cocktail Shaker?

There are a lot of different cocktail shakers and all of them come with different advantages and disadvantages. When looking into those, some things are more important than the others.

So now, I am going to talk about the important ones for choosing the right cocktail shaker for you.

I’ve both researched and field-tested some of the popular cocktail shakers on the market, and here’s what is important:

Quality Of The Lid

You have to be careful when you're choosing a cocktail shaker because some shakers won't be able to connect properly.

That can happen from time to time, or come faulty out of the box.

You have to pay attention to cocktail shaker reviews and inspect the model you’re interested in detail to be sure you’re getting the right thing.

If you happen to start shaking your cocktail in a poorly constructed shaker... good luck.

Taste Of The Drinks

I think that the taste of the drinks is the most important quality of a cocktail shaker.

If you have ever tried making the same drink with different cocktail shakers, as I have, you would know how the taste can vary.

Balance

The balance of a cocktail shaker is really important. Some professionals use them for bar flair, and I’m sure you’ll possibly try that yourself once in a lifetime.

The balance of the shaker is important for the efficiency when shaking and the ease of holding, as you might probably drop it.

Material Quality

You don't want a shaker that will get rusty before you get to use it for the second time.

In my opinion, a good-quality cocktail shaker should be made of stainless steel, and it should be built to last.

A good shaker is supposed to stay in your bar for many years.

See Also: Barbara's Best Dish Drying Racks

Availability

A product can be described as perfect, but you might have trouble finding it, which is why I think that it is important to discuss the availability of these shakers before letting you decide on what to get.

I'm sure that some of you might not consider this an important factor, but I have to note that these are the things that I've learned over the years and that I'm only speaking from experience.

Additional Stuff

Every cocktail shaker should be delivered with some certain additional stuff.

The additional stuff usually consists of a built-in strainer, jigger and an e-book of recipes.

Of course, if there are more things that come with the cocktail shaker, it's even better, but the standards should be met at least.

Price

The price of the shaker isn't the most important factor, but I'm sure that nobody would like to spend too much on a shaker, and then realize that there was one with the same qualities, but cheaper.

Of course, you shouldn't get a shaker that has no other qualities than being cheap. All that I'm saying is that it would be smarter to do some research before buying.

Current Five Best Cocktail Shakers On The Market – Barbara’s Reviews 2017

After thorough research, it’s was time for my testing. I’ve got myself some of the most popular cocktail shakers out there and here’s how they performed:

1. Cresimo 24 Set - Great Quality Stainless Steel Cocktail Shaker

Image Credit: Amazon.com

This particular cocktail shaker has dimensions of 3.3 x 3.3 x 9.4 inches, it weighs 9 ounces and has the capacity of 24 oz. This is the cobbler shaker, which is the best type in my opinion.

The quality of the lid of this product is great. You won't have issues with the lid falling off or anything similar. The only problem that might occur is that the lid gets stuck.

The taste of the drinks that I made with this shaker was just the way that is should be. I didn't notice anything wrong with the taste, and neither did my guests, which is the most important part.

This cocktail shaker is very well balanced and it will feel great in your hand.

This amazing cocktail shaker is made of stainless steel, and it is guaranteed that it won't rust, and that is another reason to love it.

This certain shaker is available at many online retailers, and I just had to notice that the shipping is really fast.

The additional items that come in the package are: a built-in strainer, 0.5 oz measurement jigger tool, a twisted bar spoon and an Illustrated Guide to Cocktails recipe guide.

Even the price of this shaker is great; it's convenient for anyone. You can't go wrong with a cocktail shaker like this and the price, which really shows value for money.

Things I Liked

  • Cobbler shaker
  • Taste of the drinks
  • Stainless steel
  • Doesn't rust or leak
  • Great quality
  • Simple to use
  • Available
  • Fast shipping
  • Price
  • 2-year warranty
  • Comes in a 4-piece set

Things I Didn't Like

  • Hard to separate
  • Lid can get stuck

2. InnoveeHome - 24 Oz of a Beautiful Cocktail Shaker

Image Credit: Amazon.com

The dimensions of this product are 7.6 x 3.7 x 3.6 inches and it weighs 1 pound. I know that this isn't one of the standards, but I just have to say that I simply adore the beautiful looks of this cobbler cocktail shaker.

The quality of the lid is great, and you can even use this one as a Boston shaker.

The drinks also taste just the way that they should - amazing. I loved the taste of the drinks that I made with this shaker and I don't mean to brag, but, the guests loved it as well.

This product is well-balanced, and it feels alright when you hold it.

Just like the first shaker that I mentioned, this one is also made of stainless steel and it doesn't rust. I have to say that it has very high quality and that it will stay in your home bar for a long period of time. And guess what? You can clean it in the dishwasher.

You will be able to find it at many online retailers, don't worry.

This shaker includes a built-in strainer, a jigger and you will receive an e-book of recipes.The price of this product is fair for the beautiful cocktail shaker that you get in return.

Things I Liked

  • Looks amazing
  • Shines beautifully
  • Taste of the drinks
  • Stainless steel
  • Doesn't rust
  • High quality
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Pretty simple
  • Available
  • Fair price
  • Great customer service
  • Balanced flavors
  • Easy to clean

Things I Didn't Like

  • Hard to separate

3. Barware Styles - Classic and Elegant Stainless Steel Cocktail Shaker

Image Credit: Amazon.com

The dimensions of this product are 9.2 x 3.5 x 3.5 inches and it weighs 12 ounces. Like I said, the looks aren't important, but I simply had to notice that it just isn't so good-looking.

The lid of this cocktail shaker is alright, although I heard that some people received a shaker with a dysfunctional lid.

I have to say that the taste of the drinks that I made with this cobbler shaker was pretty fine. The taste wasn't as amazing as the taste of the drinks that I made with the shaker that I mentioned above, but it was still good and my guests didn't complain.

My personal opinion is that this shaker isn't necessarily for professional use, so I don't think that it would be a good idea to juggle it, but it does feel alright in the hand.

Another cocktail shaker made of stainless steel? Indeed. You might have already noticed how important it is to me that the shaker is made of stainless steel, but nobody would want rust.

The only things you get with this cocktail shaker are a built-in strainer and a jigger, which is disappointing.

The price of this cocktail shaker was sort of high considering that it doesn't have any special qualities or additional items.

Things I Liked

  • Fine tasting drinks
  • Stainless steel
  • Won't rust
  • Simple and easy to use
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Functional
  • Elegant
  • Customer service

Things I Didn't Like

  • Often leak problems
  • The lid can get stuck

4. Shikshook - Professional Stainless Steel Cocktail Shaker

Image Credit: Amazon.com

Shikshook shaker is 7.7 inches tall, 3.6 inches wide, and 3.6 inches deep; it weighs 9.6 ounces. I'm personally not a big fan of how this shaker looks, but I'm sure that some of you will like it.

The lid of this cobbler cocktail shaker works well, no problems occurred while I was using it. It takes two round movements to close it tightly. The taste of the drinks was alright; no metal scent or sensation in the mouth – I can't complain.

Shikshook cocktail shaker is very well balanced, and when you hold it, it feels just right. It is made of stainless steel and it is just another cocktail shaker that won't rust or leak.

If you're looking for this particular cocktail shaker, you will be able to find it at a few online retailers, because this one isn't as popular, I guess. The shipping is pretty fast, I was impressed.

The additional items of this cocktail shaker consist of: a built-in strainer, a double jigger, 2 liquor pourers and you will get an e-book of recipes. The current price of this product is amazing, considering every feature that this cocktail shaker has.

Things I Liked

  • Taste of the drinks
  • Stainless steel
  • Won't rust or leak
  • Simple to use
  • Available
  • Fast shipping
  • Current price

Things I Didn't Like

  • Doesn't look beautiful
  • Removing the lid
  • Available only at a few online retailers

5. Bar Brat - 24 Oz of A Confusing Cocktail Shaker Bar Set

Image Credit: Amazon.com

Bar Brat shaker measures 7.6 x 3.6 x 3.6 inches and it weighs 11.2 ounces. The looks of this cocktail shaker are pretty nice, even though I wouldn't say that this is the most beautiful shaker. This is another cobbler shaker, but it can be used as a Boston shaker as well because it is versatile enough.

The lid is functional and won't allow leaks, just make sure to twist it right. Drinks made in this shaker tasted pretty fine and I simply can't complain. My guests didn't even notice anything different.

Speaking of balance, the shaker feels alright in the hand, and John tossed it around for some time, without dropping it (even though he’s a complete beginner in this skill).

Build material is standard stainless steel, and it leaves that sensation of metal on hand. The company promises that it will last for 15 years; I can't confirm that since I've only had it for a couple of months, but it still works just like it did the first day.

There aren't many online retailers from which you can order this shaker, but it’s not a wonder because it is really good.

The additional items are: built-in strainer, double size jigger, 2 pour spouts, a corkscrew and an e-book of recipes (which I didn't receive). I guess it's great that it comes with so many additional items, but it just confused me.

Things I Liked

  • Looks nice
  • Drinks tasted fine
  • Stainless steel
  • Promised to last for 15 years
  • Simple to use
  • Available
  • Fine price

Things I Didn't Like

  • A bit confusing
  • Not many online retailers sell it
  • Lid can get stuck

The Cocktail Shaker I Recommend

All of these cocktail shakers were, as you might have noticed, pretty similar. I can't surely say which one is the best, but I can say which one is my favorite.

They all had pretty much the same qualities and the same flaws, but that is only because I've selected the best ones for this.

The cocktail shaker that I recommend is Innovee Home Cocktail Shaker.

Even if we ignore its amazing looks, we are still looking at a cocktail shaker that has the most advantages and it only has one flaw, which occurs with every single one of these shakers.

If I ever find cocktail shakers that are better than these, I'll be sure to let you know 🙂

Barbara Whitney
 

For the last 20 years, I’ve been cooking, preparing, researching, and gathering recipes, tools, and knowledge about food and the way we prepare it. Raising two lively boys and spoiling one great husband later, it’s safe to say that I’ve optimized my kitchen to deliver the best possible meal, no matter the occasion.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: